Replace dashicons with material icons

[discobot]

This would make a wider variety of icons available to be used on the admin pages.

---

Read-only archive: Issues · ClassicPress/ClassicPress · GitHub

Author: Tim Kaye

Vote count: 21

Status: open

Tags:

• request-modify-feature
• difficulty-moderate

---

Comments

I think it is a good idea to look elsewhere for icons, but as per my earlier comment on GH, I think that outright replacing the dashicons can have not so great consequences as there are many plugins and themes depending on them.

Therefore, yes I am for replacing them, but we can only proceed with caution.

~ posted by Pieter Bos

I would be for extending or creating a new set to go with. Originally I was all for replacing them but the possibility of breaking things make this something I don’t want to have to worry about.

So if we change this from replace to add/expand i’m a yes vote.

~ posted by Dustin Snider

My thought is that few plugin devs will add logic to their work to support breaking changes until CP proves itself as a viable platform. In the meantime, it’s important to ensure that non-Gutenberg plugins work as seamlessly on CP as they do on WP. To that end, I’d vote no on replacement, and yes on extending or adding a new set.

~ posted by Code Potent

Agreed on not replacing Dashicons.

Even if we do add/extend our own icon set, and use it consistently throughout the ClassicPress admin dashboard, plugins will still be using dashicons.

The combination will probably look janky unless we are careful to use a similar style to dashicons.

~ posted by James Nylen

I agree on keeping Dashicons. I don’t see it as a problem that needs fixing. And it has the potential to break things.

~ posted by Alan Coggins

We should keep the dashicons as it. It is not important and recommended to leave as it is.

~ posted by Aryan Raj

Why not use CSS instead of actual images? Can be inserted using the tag ().

There’s an open API available at css.gg

~ posted by WooFunctions

[timkaye]

Since I suggested this, Dashicons have been significantly enhanced, so I no longer consider this worthwhile. This thread can be closed.